
How O Brother, Where Art Thou? Turned Green Into Dust
by Julio Song
"O Brother, Where Art Thou?" looks like a faded postcard. The fields are straw yellow, the trees are brown and the roads look like they have not seen rain in a year. None of that was in front of the camera. Joel and Ethan Coen shot the film in Mississippi in summer, and Mississippi in summer is about as green as a place gets.
The yellow came from about ten weeks in a digital suite in Hollywood, where cinematographer Roger Deakins and a colourist named Julius Friede changed the colour of the leaves by computer. In 2000 that was an odd way to finish a film. Today it is a standard step in finishing a film, and a version of the control they used sits in most photo editors.
The wrong kind of South
Deakins told "American Cinematographer" in October 2000 how the problem started. Before he had read the script, the Coens told him they wanted to shoot in the South, and that they pictured "something dry, dusty and very hot." Texas was the first choice of location. Then the production moved to Mississippi.
Deakins had already shot films in Louisiana and Alabama. He knew what was coming: a region that "would be wet and the foliage would be various shades of lush green." About half the picture took place outdoors.
A winter shoot would have helped. So would autumn. The schedule said summer. "I had to find a way to desaturate the greens," Deakins said, "and give the images we were going to shoot the feeling of old, hand-tinted postcards."

Why couldn't the lab just do it?
Film colour was set in a laboratory then, by a person called a colour timer. The timer's controls were three numbers: how much red, green and blue light to shine through the negative when printing it. Kodak's guide for film timers puts a normally exposed gray card at 25-25-25. Move a number and the whole frame moves with it. You can make a scene warmer, cooler, lighter or darker. You cannot reach in and change the trees while leaving the faces alone.
Labs had chemical tricks too, and Deakins tried them. The crew shot test footage in Griffith Park in Los Angeles, where the trees were about as green as Mississippi's would be, and handed it to Beverly Wood at Deluxe Laboratory. The tests included bleach bypass and another lab process called ACE. Both gave what Deakins called interesting desaturation. Neither could be applied selectively. The whole picture lost colour together, when only the leaves needed to.
The best of the lab options sandwiched a black-and-white copy of the film with the colour negative. That gave Deakins a dial for overall saturation. It still was not selective enough.
He had been here before. On "1984" he had used bleach bypass for a harsh, drained look, and then had to pile heavy filters on the camera for the few scenes that needed to look golden. It worked, but it meant fighting the process.
"O Brother" needed something the lab could not offer, which was a way to change one colour and leave the rest. It is the same limit that shaped the Technicolor era, when a film's palette was built on set, in paint and fabric.
The film that went first
Deakins knew of one film that had found a way round. "Pleasantville", released in 1998, is a story about a black-and-white town that slowly fills with colour. Director Gary Ross and cinematographer John Lindley shot it all on colour film, scanned it and took the colour out by computer. "American Cinematographer" counted some 163,000 frames digitised and nearly 1,700 visual effects shots.
So "O Brother" was not the first feature to pass through a computer. The magazine said so plainly at the time, and named two more: "Urbania", a Super 16 film colour-timed in a digital suite, and "The Phantom Menace", which George Lucas digitised to blend effects with live action.
What set the Coens' film apart was the reason. "Pleasantville" had a plot that could not be filmed any other way. "O Brother" had about 30 effects shots, and they had nothing to do with the decision. Deakins scanned the entire film only to control its colour. It is funny that the Coens were the ones to do it. They still cut their films on a flatbed editing table because they liked handling the film.
The scanning and recording on "Pleasantville" had been done by Cinesite in Hollywood, so Deakins went there. Some of the Griffith Park negative was scanned on a Philips Spirit DataCine at 2K resolution. Deakins sat with Friede and they picked out the greens of the trees and grass and turned them into dry browns and yellows. Cinesite then recorded the result back onto 35mm film with a Kodak Lightning laser recorder, and Deluxe made a print.
The test convinced all three filmmakers. "We knew it would be taking a risk," Deakins said, "but Cinesite gave us a good price, and quite honestly it was the only way we could see of achieving the look that all three of us wanted."
Ten weeks at Cinesite
Once the edit was locked, Deakins spent about ten weeks in the digital suite at Cinesite. It did not go smoothly, and he said so.
The first lesson was restraint. "We found that the more we tried to manipulate the image, the more noise and electronic artifacts appeared, and then we would have to rescan and retime the image," he said. "We affected the greens and played with the overall saturation but little else." Windows, the masks that let a colourist change one region of the frame, went on only a couple of shots.
Green itself fought back. Sarah Priestnall, Cinesite's director of digital mastering, called the job a learning process for everyone, and added: "Green is the most difficult color to deal with when you're converting film to digital format."
Changing one colour also changed how the others read. In one shot, an extra in an orange-yellow dress sat quietly in a crowd. Once the green behind her was drained, the dress jumped out. Deakins had Friede tone the dress down until she sank back into the scene. Any designer who has muted a background and watched a button start shouting will know the feeling. It is simultaneous contrast at work: a colour's strength depends on its neighbours.
The equipment was a struggle too. Colour was timed from the cut negative, not from a stored file, so every correction meant scanning the original negative again. The scanner, by Deakins's account, was "not even full 2K resolution", and he accepted a slight loss of sharpness as the price. He judged the film on a 16-inch monitor and worried about it, because the audience would see it on a 40-foot screen.
He was just as clear about what the method was for. "The process is not a quick fix for bad lighting or poor photography," he said. "It is a tool to be used in the same way as any other tool."
The result earned Deakins an Academy Award nomination for cinematography.

What did they actually do to the green?
The move is simple to describe. Pick a range of hues. Shift only those. Leave everything outside the range alone.
On a colour wheel measured in degrees, pure green sits at 120 and yellow at 60. The four foliage greens below sit between 80 and 127. To get something like the "O Brother" look you select that band, pull the hue down past yellow to a dull yellow-brown, and take some saturation out. Skin tones sit down in the oranges, outside the band, so they do not move. Neither does a blue sky.
Here is that recipe applied to four foliage greens. These are illustrations of the method, not colours sampled from the film. First, the greens as a summer landscape might give them to you:
Now the same four with hue moved to 42 degrees, saturation cut by a quarter and lightness untouched:
Because lightness did not change, the shapes of the trees and the modelling of the light survive. That is why the film still looks photographed. A lab process would have dragged every colour toward gray. This one changed what a single family of hues meant and left the picture's structure intact.
You can try it yourself. Paste a green into the color converter, read its HSL values, change only the hue and convert back. Photo editors call the same control HSL or "selective colour". Every one of those sliders does what Deakins and Friede did to Mississippi.
What happened next
Deakins ended his interview with a wish list. He wanted to time a stored file, not rescan the negative for each change. He wanted to judge the work projected on a big screen. Sarah Priestnall said that scanning a whole feature at 4K was impractical in 2000, and predicted it would become practical as computers and storage got cheaper.
The industry moved quickly. In September 2004, the trade paper "SHOOT" reported a forecast from Bob Eicholz of the Hollywood facility EFILM: about 35 percent of major features would have used a digital intermediate by the end of that year, and 50 percent in 2005. Looking back on the decade, "American Cinematographer" described the digital intermediate as a standard step in postproduction, and the colourist as a significant collaborator for the cinematographer.
It also changed when colour decisions get made. "O Brother" was shot green and made yellow afterwards, at a desk. Animation already planned colour away from the set. Pixar's color scripts plan a film's colour before a frame exists, and digital grading gave live action a version of the same freedom at the other end of production. Digital cameras changed the effects backdrop as well, which is why green screens are green.
What a designer can take from a chain gang
A few things here apply beyond film.
Lightness holds an image together more than hue does. You can move a hue a long way if you keep its lightness, and the result will still read as the same image. A palette treated the same way keeps its hierarchy: the dark step is still the dark step, whatever hue it wears.
A selective change still affects the colours around it. The orange-yellow dress did not change, yet it looked different once the background did. After you mute one colour in an interface or a chart, look again at everything that sits next to it.
Deakins also had a tool that could change almost any colour in the frame, and he used it on one family of hues plus overall saturation. The more he pushed, the more the image broke up. The film's look is strong partly because the change is narrow: one range of greens moved, and little else.
The Coens wanted dust, and summer in Mississippi gave them leaves. Since the leaves could not be changed on location, they were changed afterwards, in a room at Cinesite.
Sources
- Escaping From Chains: O Brother, Where Art Thou?, Bob Fisher, American Cinematographer, October 2000
- Pleasantville: Black-and-White in Color, Bob Fisher, American Cinematographer, November 1998
- A New Millennium of Screen Artistry, American Cinematographer
- For the Film Timer, Kodak
- DI In The Spot World, Carolyn Giardina, SHOOT, September 3, 2004
Written by
Designer and developer
Julio Song is a professional web designer and developer who builds and maintains ColorSift, and writes most of what is published here.
Related articles
How Pixar Invented the Color Script: Mapping a Movie's Emotions Before Anyone Draws a Frame
How Ralph Eggleston brought a pastel-on-black-paper technique from FernGully to Toy Story, and turned it into the tool that plans every Pixar film's emotional arc in color before animation starts.
Why Green Screens Are Green (and Used to Be Blue)
Film effects ran on blue screens for fifty years. Then cameras went digital, and a 1976 Kodak patent that favours green changed the backdrop colour.
The Shirley Card: How Kodak Decided What Skin Should Look Like in Color
For forty years, Kodak calibrated every color photograph against one white model. The Shirley card explains why, and why the same bias resurfaced in webcams, soap dispensers, and facial recognition.